Reference Material:
Before we consider international environmental law and climate change we need to consider domestic legislation, as it is within the sovereign states that international law is put into practice. This reflects the environmentalists’ maxim, ‘think globally act locally.’
United Kingdom legislative control over the impacts of man’s activity on the environment is not new. As long ago as the reign of Charles II the main concern was the production of smoke from the burning of sea coal. Almost all areas of trade and industry were subject to very detailed legislative controls at that time, although some were governed by ‘self- regulation’ in the form of guilds, which regulated both supply and methods of production. However, the measures implemented were mostly ineffective because then, as now, the specifying of legal duties and standards without providing any appropriate enforcement merely indicated good intentions but were of little practical effect.
The next stage was prompted by the Industrial Revolution with the urbanization of society and its profound effects on the environment. Local industrialists used the Adam Smith model to maximize their economic benefit, but this was to the detriment of the local environment with the operation of ‘Gresham’s Law’ that is, the bad drives out the good. Those industrialists who were concerned for either the health of their employees or the local environment faced higher costs than their competitors. The result was the need for increasingly comprehensive statutory controls on the discharge of pollutants into various receiving media.
Audio:
Sample Answer:
Domestic legislation should be considered before international environmental law and climate change since it put into practice within sovereign states. In the UK, Charles the Second implemented legislative controls, but the measures were ineffective because of inappropriate enforcement. Moreover, the Industrial Revolution and local industrialists who used the Adam Smith model to maximize their profits resulted in the necessity of increasingly comprehensive statutory controls on the discharge of the pollutants. (70 words)
For more real exam PTE questions and brand 9 answers, check out “All in One PTE Question Bank”.
